Summary information

Study title

The role of social identity on the 'contagious' transmission of yawning: Study 2, 2016-2019

Creator

Reicher, S, University of St Andrews
Neville, F, University of St Andrews

Study number / PID

853842 (UKDA)

10.5255/UKDA-SN-853842 (DOI)

Data access

Open

Series

Not available

Abstract

This study was designed to investigate the role of social influence on the transmission of behaviour. The study was carried out online and compared the degree to which the transmission of yawning behaviour between an actor, presented in a video, and participants was influenced by social identity; in this case, gender. There were significant main effects of ingroup/outgroup on shared identity and social identification, but not the dependent variables. Shared identity significantly predicted urge to yawn but not self-report or observed yawns. There was a significant serial moderated-mediation (Condition – [ID] – Shared Identity – Urge to Yawn – Observed Yawns). The model was also significant if observed yawns swapped for self-reported number of yawns, total duration of yawning, or time to first yawn. How and why do behaviours spread from person to person? In particular, how does aggression and violent behaviour spread? When, as in 2011, riots began in London, why did they then occur in Birmingham, Manchester, and Liverpool? One of the most common ways of addressing such issues is through the notion of 'contagion'. The core idea is that, particularly in crowds, mere exposure to the behaviour of others leads observers to behave in the same way. 'Contagion' is now used to explain everything from 'basic' responses such as smiling and yawning (where the mere act of witnessing someone yawn or smile can invoke the same response in another) to complex phenomena like the behaviour of financial markets and, of course, rioting. What is more, laboratory experiments on the 'contagion' of simple responses (such as yawning) serve to underpin the plausibility of 'contagion' accounts as applied to complex phenomena (such as rioting). Despite this widespread acceptance, the 'contagion' account has major problems in explaining the spread of behaviours. In particular, there are boundaries to such spread. If men smile at a sexist joke, will feminists also smile in response to the men's...
Read more

Methodology

Data collection period

01/05/2016 - 30/04/2019

Country

United Kingdom

Time dimension

Not available

Analysis unit

Individual

Universe

Not available

Sampling procedure

Not available

Kind of data

Numeric
Text

Data collection mode

Participants (N = 272) were recruited though Prolific, an online platform that connects researchers to participants around the world, and invited to take part in a study on how people experience and express emotions. This experiment was a 2x2 design in which male and female participants began by answering questions in part 1 of a 2-part questionnaire, hosted on Qualtrics, which was designed to make the participant’s gender salient. They then watched a 2 min 7 s video of either a male or female actor yawning during which they were filmed using their computer’s webcam. These video recordings were captured and held by a Canadian company, Nimbb. They were then redirected to complete the second part of the questionnaire which included questions about the degree to which they identified with the actor in the video, the behaviour and emotions of the actor, their tendency to experience emotional contagion measured using the Emotional Contagion Scale (Doherty, 1997) and self-reported urges to yawn. The participant videos were coded by a research assistant blind to the purpose of the study and condition, and a second naïve research assistant coded 10% of the videos.

Funding information

Grant number

ES/N01068X/1

Access

Publisher

UK Data Service

Publication year

2019

Terms of data access

The Data Collection is available to any user without the requirement for registration for download/access.

Related publications

Not available