Summary information

Study title

Television framing of the 2014 Scottish independence referendum: Coding of frames in BBC Reporting Scotland coverage of the 2016 EU referendum

Creator

Dekavalla, M, University of Stirling

Study number / PID

852601 (UKDA)

10.5255/UKDA-SN-852601 (DOI)

Data access

Open

Series

Not available

Abstract

The frames identified in the coverage of the 2014 Scottish referendum are here applied to analyse coverage of the 2016 EU referendum on the BBC's Reporting Scotland daily bulletin. The purpose of this analysis is to allow a comparison between the framing of the Scottish referendum in 2014(see Related Resources) and a small sample of equivalent Scottish coverage of the 2016 EU referendum, particularly in relation to the relative prominence of the strategic game and policy frames in the two samples. Although analysis of the EU referendum coverage was not part of the ES/L010062/1 project, a comparison of the use of the game and policy frames is made in one of the project’s outputs (Dekavalla, forthcoming monograph). These data therefore complement the coding of frames in the TV coverage of the 2014 Scottish referendum (see related resources below, part 2) by showing how prominent the same game and policy frames were in a small sample of Scottish coverage of the later referendum. The 2016 sample contains all coverage of the EU referendum on BBC Reporting Scotland in the final month of the campaign, between 23 May and 23 June 2016. This dataset contains the coding of the frames that appeared in news items. The file records the date, duration, and type of each item in this coverage and whether or not the following frames were present: policy, strategic game, relationship between England and Scotland, divorce, constitutional change, national division, self determination, and national identity. The programmes themselves are available from the broadcaster. On 18 September 2014, the Scottish electorate will be called to answer a fundamental question about the future of the UK and Scotland: the decision of whether Scotland will become an independent state or remain a part of the UK will have an impact not only on the relationship between the British nations but also on other parts of Europe with similar concerns. Yet, as is the case with any contested issue, the definition...
Read more

Methodology

Data collection period

23/05/2016 - 23/06/2016

Country

Scotland

Time dimension

Not available

Analysis unit

Text unit

Universe

Not available

Sampling procedure

Not available

Kind of data

Numeric

Data collection mode

Content analysis of recordings of televised news bulletins. The sample contains all the coverage of the EU referendum broadcast on BBC Reporting Scotland in the final month of the campaign, between 23 May and 23 June 2016. This dataset contains the coding of the frames that appeared in news items. The file records the date, duration, and type of each item in this coverage and whether or not the following frames were present: policy, strategic game, relationship between England and Scotland, divorce, constitutional change, national division, self determination, and national identity. The programmes were watched and coded for presence or absence of the frames, based on the following indicators. Indicators of game frame: emphasis on political strategy; war, game and horse-race metaphors; emphasis on who is winning or losing; reports of how the two sides are doing in polls; analyses of politicians’ performance. Indicators of policy frame: focus on policy problems, politicians’ proposals for their solution and/or their implications for the public. Indicators of identity frame: references to British distinctiveness; references to the common features and history that British people share with Europe. Indicators of self-determination frame: references to the UK making decisions separately from the EU (not specifying what decisions); references to the UK running its own affairs. Indicators of divorce frame: marriage, relationship and/or breaking up metaphors; representation of the UK and the EU as human partners or friends falling out. Indicators of national division frame: reports on division within the UK, emphasis on conflictive nature of the referendum. Indicators of Anglo-Scottish relationship frame: references to how the referendum outcome may influence the relationship between Scotland and England, speculations about what may happen if the two nations vote differently or similarly. Indicators of constitutional change frame: references to changing the status of the UK within the EU.

Funding information

Grant number

ES/L010062/1

Access

Publisher

UK Data Service

Publication year

2017

Terms of data access

The Data Collection is available from an external repository. Access is available via Related Resources.

Related publications

Not available