Summary information

Study title

SYRI Czech legal disputes about the Covid-19 pandemic 2024

Creator

Smith, Simon (Faculty of Social Sciences, Charles University)

Study number / PID

doi:10.14473/CSDA/KLFS7W (DOI)

Data access

Information not available

Series

Not available

Abstract

This corpus was constructed to explore the role played by the Czech courts, as adjudicators of legal challenges to public health measures issued during the Covid-19 pandemic, in the semiotic arrangement of ongoingness and eventfulness. The general research question was: what does this jurisprudence say about how the pandemic should unfold? The archived documents are annotated with my observations. A table of exemplary cases is also included.

Methodology

Data collection period

01/2023 - 09/2024

Country

Czech Republic

Time dimension

cross-sectional

Analysis unit

Document – Decision of the Municipal Court in Prague, Supreme Administrative Court and the Constitutional Court

Universe

Not available

Sampling procedure

I searched the databases of the Supreme Administrative Court (which also contains decisions by regional administrative courts), Municipal Court in Prague and the Constitutional Court using the keywords “Covid-19” or “pandemic” together with the term “state of emergency” (“nouzový stav”), and various temporal or processual markers such as “beginning”, “end”, “increase”, “decrease”, “culminate”, “recede”, “augment” and “diminsh”. I selected cases for further analysis based partly on a periodisation of the pandemic into resurgent phases and the calmer interludes between them (in order to include cases from both types of period) and focused mainly, but not exclusively, on decisions that overturned public health measures. The key criterion for inclusion was whether judgements claimed to express or follow any general principles about the course and temporal shape of events.

Kind of data

documents

Data collection mode

Collection of documents in Supreme Administrative Court, Municipal Court in Prague and Constitutional Court archives

Funding information

Funder

Ministry of Education, Youth and Sport of the Czech Republic, The National Institute for Research on the Socioeconomic Impact of Diseases and Systemic Risks

Grant number

LX22NPO5101

Access

Publisher

Czech Social Science Data Archive

Publication year

Not available

Terms of data access

Not available

Related publications

  • Smith, S. (2025, forthcoming) Switching Semiotic Styles during Health Emergencies: the Metachoices of Pandemic Communication. London & New York: Routledge.