Summary information

Study title

Hidden crisis project: studies of community water management in Malawi and Uganda 2017-2018

Creator

Cleaver, F, University of Sheffield
Whaley, L, University of Sheffield
Mwathunga, E, University of Malawi
Katusiime, F, Makerere University
Banda, S, University of Malawi

Study number / PID

854316 (UKDA)

10.5255/UKDA-SN-854316 (DOI)

Data access

Restricted

Series

Not available

Abstract

In developing countries, the dominant model for managing rural water supplies is a community-level association or committee. Although a relative paucity of evidence exists to support this model, it continues to exert a strong pull on policy makers. This project examines everyday water governance arrangements, situating these in the exigencies of wider village life and over the course of changing seasons. The data highlights the social embeddedness of water governance, and challenges the dominant 'associational model' of community based management. In none of the 12 sites do we observe a fully formed committee functioning as it should according to policy. Instead, water management arrangements are typically comprised by one or a small number of key individuals from the community, who may or may not be part of a waterpoint committee.Extending and sustaining access to safe and reliable water services remains central to improving the health and livelihoods of poor people, particularly women, in Africa. Here an estimated 350 million rural inhabitants still have no form of safe drinking water, and depend on poor quality unreliable sources for all their domestic needs. Improving access to water, and helping to achieve new international goals of universal access to safe water hinges on accelerated development of groundwater resources, usually through drilling boreholes and equipping them with handpumps. However, emphasis on new infrastructure has obscured a hidden crisis of failure, with 30% of new sources non-functional within 5-years and many more unreliable. This problem has remained stubbornly persistent over the last four decades, with little sign of sustained progress despite various interventions. Part of the reason for this continued failure is the lack of systematic investigations into the complex multifaceted reasons for failure and therefore the same mistakes are often repeated. The accumulated costs to governments, donors and above all rural people are...
Read more

Methodology

Data collection period

01/05/2015 - 31/10/2015

Country

Malawi, Uganda

Time dimension

Not available

Analysis unit

Individual
Family: Household family
Household
Housing Unit
Time unit
Group

Universe

Not available

Sampling procedure

Not available

Kind of data

Text

Data collection mode

Using participant diary keeping and a range of qualitative social science methods - participatory mapping, transect walks, seasonal calendars, focus groups and interviews - conducted during quarterly visits, we tracked community members’ day-to-day experiences of managing, accessing and using water. This phase provided an in-depth understanding of how a community’s relationship to water changes through the seasons and in relation to wider livelihood concerns. We employed three community diary keepers in each site in Uganda, and two in each site in Malawi. Due to logistical reasons, it was not feasible to undertake the longitudinal research in Ethiopia. Diary keepers were provided with initial training and instruction, a plastic folder with pens and blank exercise books, and a list of factors of interest to the study. At the same time, it was made clear that there is no right or wrong way of keeping a diary and diary keepers were encouraged to write freely, capturing whatever events and processes they wished to include. All diaries were written up in English on Microsoft word and stored on NVIVO.

Funding information

Grant number

NE/M008738/1

Access

Publisher

UK Data Service

Publication year

2020

Terms of data access

The UK Data Archive has granted a dissemination embargo. The embargo will end in April 2021 and the data will then be available in accordance with the access level selected.

Related publications

Not available